This information was compiled by Todd Humphrey, Practice Manager at Vaughan Integrative Medicine. He’s been a part of my organization since 2009. He’s included some very practical information on selecting supplements and has addressed an unfortunate misconception that supplements sold by specialty retailers are too expensive. Supplementation is an investment in your quality of life. You deserve the best!
- Dr. Vaughan
The use of supplements to treat the nutritional deficiencies that underlie many problematic medical conditions has long been the standard-of-care for integrative practitioners. Supplementation has emerged as a common activity of people seeking improved health and vitality. Treating nutritional needs for optimal metabolic functions–and not just addressing the deficiency-related symptoms that are associated with a medical diagnosis–has caused a dramatic increase in the use of nutritional supplements over the past several years. Choosing the right supplements, especially with the growing number of brands available on the market, can be an overwhelming task! Taking personal responsibility for your personal health and the heath of your family invites the questions: What are the best supplements to take? How do I know which products are the safest and most effective? The task requires even more discernment when you are confronted by low prices and marketing gimmicks. To help you navigate the many supplement options available on the market today, here are a few tips on choosing supplements:
It’s tempting to reach for the cheapest price when choosing supplements. The thing to remember, though, is that the “best value” does not always equate to the best quality; when it comes to correcting nutritional deficiencies, the quality of the supplements used can make an incredible difference in achieving the health you seek. Supplements are typically available in different categories: pharmaceutical grade, food grade, and agriculture grade. While agriculture grade supplements are not manufactured for human consumption and are most often utilized by veterinarians, the other types meet manufacturing requirements for humans.
Pharmaceutical-grade supplements, the highest quality grade, meet the United States Pharmacopea’s (USP) regulatory standards as verified by third-party testing for purity, dissolution, and absorption into the human body. The USP provides assurance of the purity of the capsule, certifying that each capsule contains in excess of 99% of the ingredients stated on the label. Additionally, the bioavailability (the percent of the supplement that can actually be absorbed/utilized by the body) is much higher in pharmaceutical grade supplements, especially in whole-food supplements. This grade of supplements is typically only sold by licensed health care practitioners including physicians, nutritionists, pharmacists, chiropractors, and some massage/body workers. These are typically sold without a prescription.
Food-grade supplements meet the requirements of the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) for human consumption. The FDA’s regulations are somewhat more lenient than the USP’s regulations in that the FDA allows fillers and binders such as cork byproducts, dyes, sodium benzoate, dextrose, ethycellulose, and propylene glycol. Although these ingredients are legal, in some people they can cause toxic reactions after prolonged exposure. Food grade supplements are often not tested for absorption and there is no mandate to test them for purity; some studies indicate that food grade supplements may not even contain the ingredients in the dosing as indicated on the label. This grade of supplement is most often sold by retailers unaffiliated with a licensed health care provider, like a big-box retailer.
As you shop for supplements, be sure you check the manufacturing processes of the brands you are considering. While pharmaceutical grade may be more expensive, the increased absorbability and effectiveness of the nutrients may make it a more economical purchase. Lower doses of a more absorbable nutrient will produce better results than high doses of a nutrient that contains fillers that interrupt absorption.
Read supplement labels carefully to identify the nutrient forms included in each capsule. Typically these are listed in parentheses after the name of the nutrient. While there’s no special form to look for with some vitamins, with others the natural form of the vitamin is definitely superior in efficacy. Minerals also come in various forms; elemental minerals, such as those found in soil, are not readily absorbed, so manufacturers bind them to amino acids or other substances to increase absorbability. These are called chelated minerals, and have names like magnesium succinate, calcium citrate, etc.
Generally speaking, most forms of minerals are acceptable, but there are some differences in bioavailability based on individual health status. Some people will experience poor absorption of specific vitamins or minerals because of the lack of other nutrients in the body. Achieving optimal absorption sometimes requires an empirical trial of a person’s biochemistry. Because of individual differences in the ability to absorb a nutrient, mineral supplements that contain a variety of sources are probably the best supplements to take, for example, several sources of calcium—such as carbonate, citrate, ascorbate, aspartate, and malate—can be considered to achieve different results. A physician trained in functional medicine or a well-trained supplement specialist can explain the benefits of the various forms of each nutrient.
Once you've confirmed that a nutritional supplement has the forms of the nutrients that can optimize your health, the next step is to make sure the product has enough of those nutrients to actually achieve your desired results.
Some products boast a wide range of quality ingredients. However, when you read the ingredient labels the amount of each ingredient too small to offer any therapeutic effect. This can be observed often in products that contain a blend of different nutrients, particularly those targeting specific biochemical processes or physical activities like vision, brain or joint health.
For example, a supplement blend may promote itself as having a combination of great ingredients. While the blend itself may be a formulation that carefully balances ingredients that do work together to achieve a specific health goal, in reality the doses are so low that the product doesn’t do much good.
Avoid these marketing gimmicks by knowing the recommended therapeutic dosages for key nutrients before you go shopping so that you can better identify the best supplements to take.
It is estimated that Americans now spend more than $17 Million annually on nutritional supplements. More and more companies are moving into this market vying for some of those dollars. With so many options available, it’s imperative to choose a reputable manufacturer to support your health goals.
Solid, reputable nutritional supplement manufacturers formulate supplements based on scientific research, buy the best raw materials and pay independent labs to make sure their products meet label claims and contain no contaminants. It is perfectly reasonable to contact a supplement manufacturer and ask for verification of quality. Good companies have product specs, research supporting their formulas and laboratory assays stating that their ingredients are free of contaminants and “true-to-dosage” claims made on the labels. Some of this information is available on company websites. Retailers of quality supplements will have some of this information readily available or be willing to assist you in discovering the information.
It’s incredibly important to accept that in regards to nutritional supplements, price does have bearing on the quality of the product: specifically its purity, efficacy, absorbability, and the rigor of a clean manufacturing process.
Before purchasing inexpensive or web-order brands, be sure to carefully study labels and investigate the company. Manufacturers of discount products must save money and may do it by using inadequate dosages, improper nutrient forms or other cost-cutting measures.
A simple web search will provide results of various researchers who have tested nutritional supplement products to discover that the amount of the active ingredients stated on the label deviated significantly from what was in the products. Be sure the supplements you purchase match their labels!
Information like this is available from organizations that evaluate consumer products. Consumerlab.com specializes in evaluating nutritional supplement products. The website offers reviews of a wide variety of nutritional categories, makes general recommendations, and tests products for quality and potency.
Seals of Approval
A “seal of approval” for a product typically indicates that the manufacturer has passed specific evaluation requirements. While many of these organizations are reputable, some offer an approval seal for a fee. In reality, most agencies offering an approval seal will require manufacturers to pay licensing fees each year to use their seal on products and in advertising. While the products may meet the requirements, smaller and less established companies may not be able to afford the licensing fees even though their products meet the requirements to have the seal of approval.
Seals of approval from Consumerlab.com, the Natural Products Association (NPA), the United States Pharmacopeia (USP), and others are indicative that the products are the best supplements to take.
Some nutrients maintain their potency for several years and others have a significantly shorter shelf life. Because the FDA does not require expiration dates on supplement bottles, many manufacturing companies don’t provide them. If a product does not contain an expiration date, look for a manufacturing date. When possible, purchase supplements that have been manufactured within that last year and never purchase a supplement that has met its expiration date (or will expire before you can completely use it).
Label Red Flags
Look for red flags on labels—sugar, artificial coloring and flavoring, preservatives, and additives such as shellac, chlorine and other chemicals should be avoided.
Do your own research and seek help when shopping for the best supplements to take. Ask questions of integrative physicians, functional medicine specialists, holistic nutritionists, non-conventional pharmacists, chiropractors, massage/body workers or even health-food store employees. Quality nutritional supplements can make an incredible difference in you and your family achieving optimal health and wellness. Make sure the money you spend on supplements is providing the purity you want and offering the benefits you expect. You deserve it!